Money Life with Chuck Jaffe: IPOX® CEO Josef Schuster Discusses Anthropic’s IPO

IPOX® CEO & Founder Josef Schuster joined Chuck Jaffe on the Money Life with Chuck Jaffe podcast on November 18 to discuss the upcoming IPO of Anthropic, the first large pure-play artificial intelligence company to go public. Schuster’s segment, “The Other Interview,” starts at 7:00 in the episode.
Schuster explained that the wide gap between optimists and pessimists ahead of a large listing is nothing new, and that public markets are the only place companies like Anthropic can raise capital at this scale. With estimates putting Anthropic’s market value at about $1.4 trillion, he compared the deal with SpaceX, which rose more than 20% on its debut, and noted that the average U.S. IPO gains about 17% on day one, while the median is closer to 5%.
He expects Anthropic to be volatile in its first weeks and months, trading on sentiment, short selling, leverage and underwriter support rather than fundamentals, until quarterly earnings bring more stability, as they did for SpaceX. Over time, he said, earnings growth will decide the stock’s path.
Schuster also outlined the IPOX® approach: treating IPOs as a separate equity sector for their first four years of trading, holding the largest new listings and spin-offs for more than two years on average, and including companies that buy recent IPOs. The IPOX® 100 U.S. Index is tracked by FPX (First Trust US Equity Opportunities ETF). He added that deals with moderate first-day gains of 20% to 30% have tended to perform best, while those that fall on debut have performed worst.
Listen to the full episode of Money Life with Chuck Jaffe (Josef Schuster from 7:00): ARK’s Winton: ‘Cynics make headlines, optimists make money’
Full Transcript
Chuck Jaffe: We start today’s talk on Money Life with what we call the Other Interview, because we’ve got a big interview later today. But the big deal of the day, technically at the end of today, is what we are talking about a lot on this show, and there’s nobody I’d rather talk IPOs with than Josef Schuster. He is chief executive officer at IPOX® Schuster, online at IPOX®.com. These are the people who backstop FPX, the First Trust U.S. Equity Opportunities ETF. That is an exchange-traded fund that is all about the post-IPO market, because it’s built on the IPOX® Schuster indexes. And there’s an international version, a European-focused version and more. You can learn about the ETFs, but more importantly you can learn about IPO investing, how you can do it and what is happening with the trends at IPOX®, I-P-O-X dot com.
Josef Schuster, thank you so much for taking time out of what has got to be a crazy busy time to talk with us here on Money Life.
Josef Schuster: Thank you for having me, Chuck.
Chuck Jaffe: We’ve got the big IPO from Anthropic coming out. We’ve already seen news around it, from the standpoint that it was pushed back a little bit, et cetera. There’s a wide range of potential expectations on this one. I’ve got folks saying this company is going to go gangbusters, and while it may not have a big IPO pop, it’s going to have IPO staying power. And I’ve got others saying this is a cash-out and it’s headed for trouble. I know that’s not necessarily how you look at IPOs, but start with just how unusual this IPO is, if for no other reason than its size.
Josef Schuster: It’s obviously the first pure-play AI. I think that’s the main distinguisher. We’ve had a lot of IPOs so far around AI: chip makers, data centers, infrastructure plays. But here we actually have the first really direct exposure to AI. It’s all about AI nowadays, and here comes the first big one, probably among many to come. Here it is lined up, and it’s a huge size, almost as large as SpaceX. So we’ll see what’s going to happen.
Nothing unusual, obviously, about the divergence of opinions. With large IPOs, and IPOs in general, that divergence before they go public is usually very, very large: many optimists, a lot of pessimists. This is nothing new; we have seen that before. What I can say is it’s just another really exciting point in the market, whereby these new economies and new companies shaping the future of America and the world finally make it to the market, and the average investor can participate in it. And these firms need to raise huge amounts of money to keep on growing the way they have, and the public market is the only way they can do that at this scale, at this point.
Chuck Jaffe: The estimates I’ve seen are now at $1.4 trillion in market cap. That puts them just outside the Magnificent Seven. Do IPOs that come in at the very top of the market perform differently? The IPO pop that people like and think about, does that not happen so much once we get past a certain size, just because it can’t?
Josef Schuster: What I can say in that respect is that this is only the second really huge IPO, larger than a trillion dollars. That hasn’t happened before. But we have had SpaceX performing significantly higher than the offering price. They left a lot of money on the table; SpaceX popped about 20-plus percent. So for Anthropic, there’s no reason it cannot pop as well.
The average U.S. IPO pops around 17%. The median, however, is much smaller: 5%, 5.5%. The larger pops really come from the excitement about venture-capital-backed deals, companies with a very, very fast growth trajectory. There are estimates that in a few years’ time, the company may still look cheap at the levels where it’s going public now. We don’t know. All we know, from our perspective, is that it’s an important company within the IPO cycle, within an IPO-focused portfolio, and you need to treat it accordingly and invest in it accordingly, alongside other recent IPOs.
Chuck Jaffe: You mentioned SpaceX. When it came out in mid-June, it priced at $135 a share. It was $160 a share when it opened. It rallied very quickly, in a couple of days, to over $225 a share, and then it plunged in the summer. Is that a logical pattern we might expect here? Not necessarily in the same magnitude, but: there’s all the excitement, people want to get these shares, there are funds that will have to own them, indexes that will have to start including them pretty quickly, and all that sort of stuff. So we will have some measure of initial gain because we almost have to. But is the real measure going to be what happens months from now? And we’ll talk in a moment about what that does for an index like yours.
Josef Schuster: All we can say about Anthropic is that it’s a certainty it’s going to be a volatile stock. It will not trade off fundamentals at all in the first few weeks, even months, of trading. Just like SpaceX, it trades off sentiment, short selling, leverage, underwriting support, all sorts of things that have nothing to do with fundamentals. As fundamentals start to come in through the quarterly earnings, we’ll probably see more stability in the stock, but until then it’s going to be very volatile.
SpaceX, as you realize, has had a pretty wide range. It stabilized quite nicely after the first earnings report, and even more so after the second, as positive company news came out. We can expect the same kind of dynamics for Anthropic. On the one hand, you’re going to have a lot of index buying supporting the company, investors buying the company. On the other hand, you’re going to see a lot of short selling as well, given that the float is so small, and I think there’s a significant hedge fund trade here too. All we know is it’s going to be an exciting, high-volume, high-growth company. The proof of the pudding will be in the eating: eventually it’s going to be everything about earnings growth. If growth expectations are not met, the stock is in for a hard landing. But nobody is expecting that at this point.
Chuck Jaffe: How does this play out when it comes to the ETF and the index, in terms of how long an IPO is, in your mind, an IPO? How long does an IPO have unique performance characteristics relative to an established stock?
Josef Schuster: Our philosophy at IPOX®, which we pioneered about 20 years ago, has been that IPOs should be considered a separate equity sector, if not an asset class, and not just for one or two months. It’s really for the first four years of aftermarket trading. That’s where the real action happens.
We take a buy-and-hold perspective on the largest IPOs, which we source from our large underlying universe, and then we apply a quarterly rebalancing process to the portfolio. We hold stocks on average more than two years. An important component of the portfolio has also been pooling IPOs and spin-offs together. So with IPOX® and with the FPX ETF, you get a systematic, broad-based portfolio of recent IPOs, with IPOs defined as deal flow that happened up to four years ago.
Nowadays we also at times include companies that have bought IPOs, because IPO M&A has been really, really strong. The IPO market nowadays is not just a venture capital market like the late ’90s. It’s also a buyout market, a takeover market, where large incumbents are buying IPOs in order to grow. It’s been a really interesting trade as well.
Chuck Jaffe: When we look at the big IPOs that have the bigger pop, you talked about how that’s the exception, not the rule, and a much smaller move is the norm. Is there also a different pattern? We talked about what happened with SpaceX and what could happen with Anthropic. When you look at it, do IPOs generally have a smoother or better ride over that two-year period if they don’t have all the hype at the beginning, versus the ones with the initial pop and all that volatility because they’re not trading on fundamentals?
Josef Schuster: Yeah, that’s actually quite interesting. The data shows the companies that pop relatively modestly, between 20 and 30 percent, actually perform better. The companies that perform worst are actually the ones with a negative initial return. So we actually say: don’t leave any money on the table.
That’s the interesting bit about IPOs. One predictive element is that you don’t want to buy companies that don’t do well at the opening. You want to buy companies that do well at the opening. It’s a very strong signal: the market is forecasting that this company will eventually do pretty decently as well.
But again, from our perspective, we look at the IPO opportunity set across a large number of companies. With FPX, we track 100. Our benchmarks are mid-caps, the Russell and the S&P, and our goal is that at the end of the day the investor knows where he or she stands against those benchmarks. And so far, so good. Over 20 years, there’s been a really interesting, good asset-allocation case for using the approach we pioneered.
Chuck Jaffe: Josef, really interesting stuff. I appreciate you taking the time out again, during what has got to be a crazy busy time, to join me on Money Life. We will talk to you more down the line.
Josef Schuster: Thank you so much for having me, Chuck.
Chuck Jaffe: That’s Josef Schuster, chief executive officer at IPOX® Schuster, IPOX®, I-P-O-X dot com. Again, the ETF we were talking about is FPX, that’s the ticker symbol, and there’s FPXE and FPXI, the international versions, and more. You can get details at IPOX®.com.
Source: Money Life with Chuck Jaffe – ARK’s Winton: ‘Cynics make headlines, optimists make money’ (by Chuck Jaffe – published November 18, 2026)
